A Secret Engagement

We started talking about marriage about 3 months into dating.  We both just knew this was it, so no sense in avoiding the topic.  We talked about how big the wedding would be, when it would be, where it would be.  Up until the month before we actually got engaged, neither of us contemplated a secret engagement, let alone a secret wedding.
 
We had been trying to plan a vacation for months and finally decided that we would join Leslie’s parents for a week at Watercolor, the resort community along 30A in the Florida panhandle.  Watercolor is one of Leslie’s favorite places and she was excited to spend the week there with Bennett and her parents.  Leslie’s parents had to go back to Tallahassee for a night early in the week, and Bennett had planned to use this evening to propose.  

Oblivious to Bennett’s plan, Leslie saw the evening as an opportunity to run over to Destin to do some outlet shopping.  So off we went, Leslie leading the way through various outlet shops, pointing out all the good deals on luggage, socks and undershirts.  It got so late that the stores finally closed, forcing her to leave. Bennett suggested grabbing a late dinner, and we wound up at a pizza place right on the beach in Seaside.  It was late, and only two other tables were still there.  After enjoying great pizza and even better red wine, Bennett pointed out how pretty the moon looked and suggested we walk down to the beach to check it out.  

As we got to the beach, we both looked around and realized that we were the only ones out there.  Leslie laughed and looked up at the full moon, while Bennett got down on his knee.  

Not realizing what was happening, Leslie turned around and got down on her knees to face Bennett.  It was then she exclaimed, “ARE YOU PROPOSING RIGHT NOW?!”  (Spoiler alert: He was.)  

The rest was a bit of a blur, but when we walked back up from the beach we could hear “Home” by Edward Sharpe and the Magnetic Zeros playing over the restaurant speakers.  Leslie stuck her head into the (now closed) restaurant and excitedly told the staff we had just gotten engaged.  Then we danced right there in the middle of the restaurant courtyard before going home to call our parents with the news.

 

Planning (Or Lack Thereof)

We thought that keeping the guest list to under 20 people would make planning our wedding easy.  We'd been engaged about 12 hours when we realized that wasn't necessarily the case...

Bennett said from the very beginning that he only had two requirements for the wedding: (1) we had to get married somewhere Barbara could legally marry us and (2) we couldn’t allow the wedding to cause us unnecessary stress.  Leslie had a few more requirements, which probably surprises no one. 

Bennett's work schedule meant that traveling anywhere would be difficult, and it also meant that we would be staying in Atlanta for the Christmas holidays.  It was already September, but we figured why not ask our families to come to Atlanta for Christmas, and we could just get married while they were here?  

While our parents were not pleased about keeping this a secret, they embraced the idea of coming to Atlanta for Christmas and staying afterwards for a wedding. 

Venue and Vendors

With our families on board, we started looking for a venue. Turns’ out, finding somewhere to have a 20-person wedding is hard - almost every venue would have dwarfed us.  After a few frustrating weeks, Bennett stumbled upon the website for Rhodes Hall.  Built in 1904 as a private home, it is now a museum and the headquarters for The Georgia Trust for Historic Preservation.  After taking a tour, we decided it was perfect and immediately booked it.  This was in October, about two months before the wedding.

Once we found a location, the other necessities were quickly locked down. We booked Sun In My Belly, a fantastic local restaurant, as the caterer. We spent a lot of time looking for a photographer.  When we saw W. Scott Chester's portfolio, we knew he was special.  As you'll see in the wedding photos, he has a knack for finding the perfect light, that creative perspective, and the amazing candid.  We got our photos back a few weeks ago and cannot stop drooling over them. 

We met with Ashley Baber, of Ashley Baber Weddings, in mid-October. Once she was on board, the rest took care of itself.  Usually when you are planning a wedding you have an abundance of time.  While it was stressful to plan a secret wedding in just a few months, at least we didn't have time to second-guess ourselves!

Our Unsung Heroes

We could not have been happier with how everything turned out, and we could not have done it without help.

Leslie's parents ran around town on Christmas Eve picking up place cards and menus from the printer and ordering desserts for the wedding.  Her dad and Man of Honor, Matthew Navarrete, stocked the bar the day after Christmas.  When Leslie lost the marriage license the day before the wedding, Leslie’s parents ransacked her condo to find it (Matthew eventually located it within some files in the back seat of Leslie’s car). Leslie's mom made sure everyone had directions, and she took charge of the tipping and thank-you cards in the hours before the wedding, making sure that Leslie had one less thing to keep track of.  Katie Brandewie, Leslie's Matron of Honor, ran to Target the morning of the wedding to make a "Surprise!" sign for us to use in our pictures.  Katie's husband, Brooks Brandewie, not only made a liquor run the day of the wedding, he also spent hours splicing "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" with "Happy" so that Bennett could surprise his mom during the Mother of the Groom dance. And when our iPod playlist didn't work according to plan, Brooks spent the evening DJ-ing for us. 

Bennett's parents hosted an incredible fiesta-themed rehearsal dinner at La Urbana - our favorite Mexican restaurant.  Karen went above and beyond with the rehearsal dinner decor - think maracas, lanterns, and even a sombrero for Bennett.  Bennett's brother and Best Man, John, spent hours setting up the rehearsal dinner slide show through the TV at the restaurant. Sara and her husband Matt wrangled their three small children, dressed in formal wear, and somehow got them to sit quietly through the entire ceremony.  The day of the wedding, Bennett's mom hemmed Charlie and Watson's tuxedo pants, and when Matthew's tuxedo ripped 30 minutes before the wedding, Karen stitched it right up. 

When we look back on that day, what is striking is that no matter how big or small our ask, the only answer we heard was "yes".  It is pretty incredible to be surrounded by that kind of love and support, and we will always be grateful to those who helped make that day so special.

OUR PEOPLE

In Bennett's Corner:

152 2014-12-08 10.29.08.jpg
 
 

In Leslie's Corner: 

580595_10103334924955471_240145332_n.jpg
 

John Skilling - Best Man

John is Bennett's best friend and brother.  As children, they were boy scouts together, they suffered through church and Sunday school together, and caused trouble together.  Growing up, Bennett picked on John all the time, and John usually ratted Bennett out to their parents.   But as they got older, Bennett stopped antagonizing John and became a protective big brother.  In high school they spent endless hours in the room over the garage playing their guitars, but the two really bonded during their time together at Auburn.  They have been best friends ever since.  While Bennett is not a fan of talking on the phone, he and John can talk for hours.  He’s always known John would be his Best Man. 

 

Katie Brandewie - Matron of Honor

Leslie and Katie have been best friends since Ms. Putnal’s first grade class.  The two were an obvious match.  Katie danced and wore gigantic bows and Leslie played soccer and wore leopard print "Hammer" pants.  Despite their differences, the two have spent the last 25 years laughing together, teasing each other, and supporting one another.  The fact that they’ve remained friends so long is not a surprise to anyone who knows Katie – she is a dedicated friend and works hard to maintain her friendships, which is just one of Katie’s qualities that Leslie admires.  When Bennett and Leslie started talking about how to pull off this wedding, Leslie said that Katie is her family, so getting married without her there was not an option.

Matthew Navarrete - Man of Honor

Matthew and Leslie briefly crossed paths at the University of Florida (GO GATORS!) when Leslie graduated and Matthew moved into her old room.  A year later, they ended up at Emory Law School together, and from the first day of orientation, Leslie knew that Matthew was someone who would be a friend for life.  They have been each other's enablers ever since. Matthew and Leslie share a mutual love for Publix carrot cake, bourbon, fur coats and Darnell’s.  While they each refer to the other as “Lover!”, neither can quite recall why.   They both moved to DC after law school and became roommates, which only resulted in more late-night trips to get mozzarella sticks from the Chinese/Wings/Burgers restaurant around the corner.  Matthew has provided countless laughs, perfect high-kicks and invaluable advice and support over the years, and Leslie couldn’t imagine not having him by her side on her wedding day.

 

Rehearsal 

We’re all intelligent people and capable of standing in place, so at first I thought with a wedding our size a rehearsal wasn’t necessary.  Turns out, there are some logistics associated with this stuff, which was fortunate because the rehearsal dinner is Leslie’s favorite part of any wedding, and we couldn’t have a rehearsal dinner without a rehearsal. 
 
We were a motley crew, with Bennett showing up directly from work in his neon green “Recruit” uniform.  Leslie had just spent the better part of the afternoon moving them into the hotel and frantically searching for the missing wedding license.  Katie and Brooks and Barbara and Ellis had just driven up from Tallahassee.  Ted had just flown in from Rhode Island.  And Karen and John had just spent the afternoon decorating La Urbana for the rehearsal dinner.    To Vicki’s surprise, Leslie wore her mom’s wedding dress to the rehearsal.  One of Leslie’s favorite memories from the weekend was the look on Vicki’s face when she recognized the dress.  While it took us a while to get started, we managed to do a few dry-runs with the ever impressive Ashley Baber leading the charge.
 
Once we got through the rehearsal, it was time for Mexican food and margaritas.  From the maracas on the tables to the lanterns hanging from the ceiling, Karen went all out on the decorations.  A slide show of Bennett and Leslie, which David put together in a real labor of love, played on the flat-screen TV in the corner of the room.

Upon our arrival, Karen handed an enormous sombrero to Bennett and a white halo (head wreath) to Leslie.  And once the food started coming, it didn’t stop.  The way Leslie ate, you’d never guess that she would be trying to fit into a wedding dress the next day!  

The highlight of the evening, from Leslie’s perspective, was when Karen and Frank gave Leslie a book of letters they’d written to Bennett since he was born.  The letters are periodic memories, updates on how he was doing at the time, who his friends were, what he enjoyed.  To give your child, and their spouse, that kind of insight into who he was as a kid, it is an incredible gift for which we are both grateful.
 
The night ended shortly thereafter, with everyone turning in early to rest up for the day ahead…

 

Let's Get Married!

The morning of the wedding, despite all of the things still left to do, Leslie was determined to get some of her nervous energy out.  She woke up early and took a nice long walk with her parents through Lullwater Park on Emory’s campus.

Bennett and John ran errands that morning, not least of which was a stop at DSW to pick up some shoes for John to wear with his tuxedo. Bennett, dressed in his lounge clothes, recalls walking through the lobby that morning with his tuxedo, a 12-pack of Coors Light and his dob kit and thinking, “I can’t believe I’m carrying a tuxedo, about to get married, and I’m wearing crocs in public.”  Luckily he ditched the crocs.   

Back at the hotel afterwards, Leslie popped the champagne and began getting ready.  Matthew, Katie and Vicki joined her for hair and make-up. Unbeknownst to Leslie, Katie had woken up early to make a run to Target.  Katie knew that Leslie had wanted, but been unable to find, a “Surprise!” sign to hold while the photographer took photos for the announcements.   There in the hotel room, while Leslie was having her make-up done, Katie managed to work her magic, and pulled together the perfect sign using materials she purchased at Target earlier that morning.   At the same time, Brooks stopped by to visit and, upon seeing Leslie’s frustration with the music and wedding playlists, promptly took her laptop and spent the next two hours splicing “Somewhere Over the Rainbow” with “Happy” so that it transitioned at the perfect time.  

Meanwhile, in a room just down the hall, Bennett and his family were also getting dressed. When Scott, the photographer, arrived to take some photos of the guys getting ready, he found them struggling with their bow ties.  He set the camera down and rescued them, quickly tying their ties so they wouldn’t be late.  

By 2:00 p.m., Leslie’s group was on its way to Rhodes Hall, with Bennett and John close behind them.  Bennett vividly remembers he and John, in their tuxedos, climbing into the car.  John turned to Bennett and said, “Alright man, this is it. You ready?”   Bennett said, “Hell yes” and started the car.   Like a scene from a movie, the radio came on and they immediately heard the chorus to “Another One Bites the Dust” which caused both of them to die laughing.  

In the bridal suite at Rhodes Hall, Leslie began getting dressed.  When the wait staff walked in with champagne, Katie exclaimed, "Look at the bottle!”  Leslie’s dad had surprised her and Bennett by ordering a case of custom-labeled champagne, which brought Leslie to tears.  

Once she was dressed, Bennett, nervous and excited, stood outside waiting for Leslie and their "first look."  When he turned around and finally saw her, he remembers thinking that he’s never seen Leslie look more beautiful.  Leslie remembers that when Bennett turned around and she saw him for the first time, it was like all of her nerves and anxiety evaporated.  They hugged and kissed, and each of them teared up, while Scott captured everything perfectly.  

It feels like the rest of the day flew by.  Pretty soon it was time for the ceremony to begin. Bennett and his family, followed by Matthew and Vicki, then Katie, all processed down the aisle to “Promontory” from the movie Last of the Mohicans.  David then walked Leslie down the aisle while Louis Armstrong’s “La Vie en Rose” played.  When Bennett saw Leslie walk down the aisle, it took his breath away.  Leslie remembers just locking eyes with him and seeing nothing else, including Watson who was apparently relieving himself off the side of the porch at that exact moment!  (Leslie’s only regret from the day is that there is not a photo of this.) 

Barbara began by welcoming everyone, explaining that the day held special significance for the couple because Bennett’s grandparents, Grammy and Pop Pop Watson, were married on the same date over 50 years ago.  Barbara handed the wedding rings around, asking our families and friends to silently say a prayer and make a wish for the couple as each held and passed the rings.  Sara then stood up and shared a reading she had chosen for the occasion, of which Leslie’s favorite excerpt is below. 

And stand together yet not too near together
For the pillars of the temple stand apart
And the oak tree and the cypress grow not in each other’s shadow.
— Kahlil Gibran, The Prophet

We remember listening to Sara’s reading and each thinking about how perfect the message was.

Next it was time for Bennett and Leslie to share their vows.  As Bennett read his to Leslie, he just remembers seeing Leslie, Katie and Leslie’s parents all tearing up.  Heartfelt and moving, each with a touch of humor, we’ve included them in their entirety below.  

Bennett’s Vows to Leslie: 

Leslie,

Within two hours of being with you, I knew you were someone I wanted to spend a lot of time with.  Within 48 hours, I knew you the only person I wanted to date.  Within one week, I knew I was madly in love with you.  And within one month, I knew I wanted to spend the rest of my life with you.  
A very wise person once told me that, “True love is not being able to imagine your life without the other person.” 

Everyday that I’m alive is another opportunity for me to experience your beauty, your intelligence, your sense of humor, your positivity, your encouragement, and your ability to make me a better person.  

In my eyes, you are perfect.  You are my best friend, my favorite person to be around, and I can no longer imagine my life without you. 

So, for the rest of my days, I vow to hold you above all others, stand by your side, and love you unconditionally.  I will protect you with my life, pick you when you are down, and comfort you when you in need.  I promise to work every day to be the husband you deserve and give you everything that I have physically, spiritually, and emotionally.  

My love for you is eternal, and I vow to give you that love forever. 

Leslie’s Vows to Bennett: 

It isn’t often that reality surpasses your wildest expectations.  And it is no secret that I’ve had a crush on you for over a decade.  But you are, in reality, a more wonderful man than I could have ever hoped for. 

You are kind and supportive.  You are funny and smart.  You are sensitive and strong.  And you are silly.  You give me a sense of security that I never realized I needed.  

There is no one I’d rather sit on the couch with, share a meal with, or explore the world with.  There is no one I’d rather fight with and no one I’d rather fight for.  You are my best friend. 

So here, in front of those who love us most, I promise you this: 

I promise to always be your number one fan and your partner in crime.  I promise to laugh with you, cry with you, learn with you, and grow with you.  I promise to listen to you and be kind to you, even when we disagree.  I promise to support your dreams and respect our differences.  I promise to build a life with you full of laughter, understanding and love.  

Today, and every day from here on out, I choose you.  And I feel so lucky that you choose me, too.  

After they exchanged rings, Leslie remembers the pure giddiness she felt when Barbara finally pronounced them husband and wife.  We walked back up the aisle to “Home” by Edward Sharpe and the Magnetic Zeros, with Bennett throwing a fist-pump into the air.

Then it was time to celebrate! 

Bennett snuck some pulled pork corn muffins, and Leslie grabbed the champagne.  After exchanging lots of hugs and kisses with everyone, we went back outside for family portraits and then it was up to the roof to get some photos of the skyline.  We took a few minutes alone to relax in the bridal suite eating appetizers and toast one another with champagne before coming back downstairs where we shared our first dance to the Alabama Shakes’ “Found You.”  When Bennett caught Leslie off-guard with a dramatic dip, Leslie almost surprised him, and everyone else in the room, with a near wardrobe malfunction. 

After our first dance, we sat down together at one long table in the main room and enjoyed an amazing family-style spread from Sun in My Belly.  We ate and drank and laughed.  Matt even commented on our "classy" selection of background music (think Jon Bon Jovi on strings).

As dinner neared the end, the toasts began, and before we knew it, practically everyone at the table had gotten up to toast us.  John and Sara talked about their love for Bennett and how happy they were that he’d found Leslie.  Katie embarrassed Leslie with stories of how hard she tried to get Bennett’s attention in high school.  Matthew told the group about his friendship with Leslie and how much he’s enjoyed getting to know Bennett.  Barbara spoke about how Bennett was her “oldest son.”  She remembered when Bennett came home from that first trip to Atlanta and listening to him talk about Leslie, she knew Leslie was special.  Frank gave a touching toast about the two families coming together and how much they’d enjoyed getting to know Leslie and her parents.  Bob, Leslie’s grandfather, told a story about when Leslie was a child and flying to see them in Orlando, asking a flight attendant to upgrade her to first class, exclaiming to the table that Leslie was “still first class!”  

Leslie’s dad spoke last, confessing to the group that when Bob toasted him and Vicki at their wedding, neither understood what he meant.  The longer they’ve been married, the more they realize how right Bob was.  Ending the toast with the same words Bob said to them more than 37 years ago, David raised a glass and said,

“Friendship is the true basis of marriage. Our wish for you is that, on this day each year, you can look at one another and say, ‘You are my best friend.’”

There were tears and hugs all around, and then Leslie and David shared a dance to “Father and Daughter” by Paul Simon.  Afterwards, Karen and Bennett danced to “Somewhere Over the Rainbow” that, half way through, switched to “Happy” by Pharrell.  Karen, surprised that Bennett had actually gone along with her request for the song, really started to break it down.  She encouraged everyone to join them on the dance floor, so we did!  The rest of the evening was spent dancing, laughing, drinking, joking and loving.
  
At the end of the night our Uber was a no-show. Ever the optimists, Bennett and Leslie seized the moment.  They piled into the back of their SUV with Katie, Brooks, Matthew, Ted and John, and 15 minutes later the crew walked into the Majestic Diner for milkshakes.

Afterwards, the group went back to the hotel where they ran into Vicki, Karen and Betty, Leslie’s grandmother, visiting and drinking wine in the hotel lobby.  The group joined them, finishing off much of the leftover booze from the wedding.

The next morning, Leslie’s parents threw a post-wedding brunch at Canoe.  There, in the wine room, everyone joined together for one last meal before parting ways – a wonderful way to cap off the festivities.